HEY vs Fastmail: Which Email Provider Is Right for You?
HEY wants to reinvent how you handle email, while Fastmail wants to fit however you already work. I used HEY for about a year and Fastmail as my main email for a considerable time, so here's my honest comparison of the two, with prices checked against both sites.
Jump to section
Features checked 5 October 2026, prices rechecked 17 October 2026, wording refreshed 9 November 2026
I’ve used both of these as my main email. I spent about a year on HEY before moving on, and Fastmail was my main email for a considerable time. They’re both paid services with no adverts, but they go about email in completely different ways, and which one suits you really comes down to how you like to work.
HEY is made by 37signals, the team behind Basecamp, and it gives you one particular way of handling email that you fit in with. Fastmail has been around since 1999 and does the opposite: it works with whatever mail app you like and lets you organise things your own way.
Short answer: choose Fastmail if you want your own domain, the freedom to use any mail app and the lower price ($60 a year for Individual, with your own domain included). Choose HEY if you like the idea of the Screener and a set way of working, and you’re happy to use HEY’s own apps, as it doesn’t support IMAP. For most people, I’d say Fastmail is the safer and cheaper choice.
HEY vs Fastmail at a glance
| HEY | Fastmail | |
|---|---|---|
| Personal plan | $99/year HEY for You, yearly billing only | $60/year Individual, or $6 month to month |
| Your own domain | From $10/month Separate HEY for Domains plan | Included On Individual, Duo, Family, Standard and Professional |
| Storage | 100 GB per person | 60 GB on Individual 150 GB per person on Professional |
| Mail apps | HEY’s own apps only No IMAP or POP | Any app JMAP, IMAP, SMTP, CardDAV, CalDAV |
| Sorting | Screener, Imbox, The Feed, Paper Trail | Folders or labels, plus rules |
| Aliases | On HEY for Domains only | Masked Email, with 1Password and Bitwarden |
| Built in AI | None | None |
| Data location | United States | United States or EU (Amsterdam) |
| Free trial | Yes, no card needed | 30 days |
| How it works | One set way of handling email, designed for you | Build your own way with folders, labels and rules |
| Calendar | HEY Calendar included | Fastmail calendar included Syncs with other apps over CalDAV |
| Tracking protection | Tracking pixels blocked, and it tells you who tried | Remote images blocked until you ask |
| If you leave | MBOX and vCard export @hey.com mail forwarded for life after one paid year | Standard IMAP export Your own domain moves with you |
| Company based in | United States | Australia |
Prices in US dollars, as listed by each provider and rechecked on 17 October 2026.
My year on HEY
I gave HEY a proper go. I started with a personal @hey.com address, later tried it with my own domain, and used it as my main inbox for about a year. There was plenty I liked, but over time a few things started to wear on me.
- The look. What felt fresh at first started to feel a bit playful for serious work. That’s a matter of taste, and lots of people love HEY’s design, but it never quite sat right with me.
- No other mail apps. I mostly use webmail anyway, so that wasn’t the problem on its own. The problem is that HEY doesn’t support IMAP or POP at all, so you can’t use it in Apple Mail, Outlook or anything else. It can send as another address, but it won’t collect mail from your other accounts. You use HEY’s apps or nothing, and over a year that felt more and more closed in.
- All the sorting. HEY doesn’t sort things for you the way Gmail’s tabs do. Every new sender is a decision you make yourself, and tools like Reply Later, Set Aside and Bubble Up each add a step. For me, that meant more clicks between me and the emails I actually needed to answer.
I go into all of this in my full HEY email review.
What HEY does really well
I don’t want this to sound like I’m knocking HEY, because some of its ideas are brilliant.
- The Screener deals with emails from strangers better than any spam filter I’ve used. A new sender’s first email waits until you say yes or no, and if you say no, you never hear from them again.
- Tracking pixels are blocked, and HEY tells you when a sender tried to track you.
- HEY Calendar is included in the price, along with handy extras like Clips, Collections, Merge Threads, Sticky Notes and Workflows.
- HEY World, the simple blogging tool on personal plans, is a nice touch.
There’s one policy I really wish other providers would copy. If you pay for at least your first year and later close your account, HEY will forward anything sent to your @hey.com address to another address, free, for life. Nobody else can take your old address either. On HEY for Domains you own the domain anyway, so you simply point it somewhere else.
Why Fastmail is still my favourite
Fastmail was my main email for a considerable time, and as a pure email service I still think it’s the best all round provider you can get. These days my work runs through Google Workspace, but that’s because I need shared documents and video calls in one place, not because Fastmail let me down. I explain that in my Fastmail review.
- It works your way. Folders or Gmail style labels, rules that file things automatically, and any mail app you like. It never asks you to change how you work.
- Your own domain and Masked Email. Adding my domain took under ten minutes. Masked Email gives you a different address for every site you sign up to, straight from 1Password or Bitwarden, and it was the feature I used most. I explain why in masked email vs disposable email.
- It’s quick. Searching tens of thousands of emails comes back in under a second, and it’s always been fast from here in the UK. A March 2026 update added compose in its own window, inline replies and a reading pane you can put below the message list.
- Support is good. Whenever I’ve needed help, their email support has been fast, friendly and knowledgeable.
- It costs less. Individual is $60 a year against HEY’s $99, and it includes your own domain, which on HEY means a separate plan from $120 a year.
- Privacy. Fastmail blocks remote images by default, supports passkeys and two factor sign in, and since August 2026 lets you keep your mail on its own servers in Amsterdam at no extra cost. It’s honest that backups and system logs stay in the US, and it’s still an Australian company. I go into this in my Fastmail privacy deep dive.
Where Fastmail falls short
To be fair to HEY, Fastmail has nothing quite like the Screener, so you’d need to set up rules to get close. Its design is clean and practical rather than exciting. Personal plans have less storage than HEY (60 GB against 100 GB). And if what you really want is end to end encryption, Fastmail isn’t built for that. I compare it with a service that is in Proton Mail vs Fastmail.
AI in your inbox
Credit where it’s due, both have landed in the same place on AI, and it’s the place I’d want. Neither has AI writing, summarising or sorting your mail. HEY launched a command line tool in September 2026 that lets you connect an AI agent you already use, and Fastmail launched an MCP server in April 2026 that does the same for the assistant of your choice. Both are entirely optional.
As much as I’m a fan of AI, I’m not a fan of AI in my email. My inbox holds some of the most personal and sensitive things I have, and I don’t want a provider’s AI reading it in the background. If I ever want an assistant to help with my calendar or draft a reply, I’d rather connect a tool I already trust, with the permissions I choose. Fastmail lets you give read, write and send access separately, which is exactly how it should be.
How each one asks you to work
HEY replaces the usual inbox with its own system:
- The Screener: new senders wait until you say yes or no.
- The Imbox: important mail from people you’ve said yes to.
- The Feed: newsletters and offers, shown as one long scrolling page.
- Paper Trail: receipts and the like, filed away quietly.
You decide which sender goes where and can change your mind later, but you can’t swap HEY’s system for a normal inbox with folders. If it suits you, that’s great. If it doesn’t, there’s no other mail app to fall back on.
Fastmail leaves it up to you. Its rules can do a lot of what HEY does, such as filing newsletters and receipts into their own folders, or putting mail from people who aren’t in your contacts into a folder to check later. It works with Apple Mail, Outlook, Spark, Thunderbird and others, as well as its own apps, and your calendar and contacts sync with Apple devices and most desktop apps, and with Android through Fastmail’s app or a tool like DAVx⁵.
Prices compared
All prices are in US dollars, as listed on each provider’s pricing page on 5 October 2026 and rechecked on 17 October 2026. Paid month to month, Fastmail’s Individual, Duo and Family plans are $6, $10 and $14 a month.
Personal use
| HEY | Fastmail | |
|---|---|---|
| One person, provider’s address | $99/year HEY for You, 100 GB, yearly only | $60/year Individual, 60 GB, or $6 monthly |
| One person, your own domain | $120/year HEY for Domains, $10/month, monthly only | $60/year Individual, domain included |
| Two people | $179/year HEY Family, up to 5 people | $96/year Duo, 60 GB each |
| A family | $179/year HEY Family, up to 5 people | $132/year Family, up to 6 people |
| Short vanity address | $349/year 3 characters, $999/year for 2 characters | Not needed Use your own domain |
Fastmail prices are billed yearly unless stated. HEY’s short address prices are as listed on 5 October 2026.
Business and teams
| HEY for Domains | Fastmail | |
|---|---|---|
| Price per person | $12/month $10 for the first person, monthly billing | From $3/month Basic $3, Standard $5, Professional $9, billed yearly |
| Storage per person | 100 GB | 6, 60 or 150 GB Basic, Standard or Professional |
| Your own domain | Yes | Standard and Professional Not on Basic |
| Team extras | Shared threads, private comments Group addresses via Extensions | Shared folders, calendars and contacts Email archive on Professional |
Fastmail also offers discounts for two and three year terms. At the time of writing, Individual drops to $4.67 a month on a 36 month plan.
Put simply, Fastmail costs less to start with, and the gap gets bigger once you want your own domain. On your own with your own domain, you’ll pay roughly half as much on Fastmail. HEY does give you more storage, a calendar and blog included, and the forwarding for life promise on @hey.com addresses.
Which should you choose?
| I’d pick HEY if… | I’d pick Fastmail if… |
|---|---|
| you’re fed up with email and would like an app that gives you a set way of dealing with it | you want a reliable, flexible email service with lots of features |
| you’re happy using HEY’s own apps and don’t need other mail apps or links to other tools | you like using Apple Mail, Outlook, Spark or another mail app |
| emails from strangers are your biggest headache, and the Screener sounds like a dream | you have your own domain and want Masked Email |
| you like the forwarding for life promise | you want clean, professional webmail at a lower price |
What I liked and what to be aware of
| What I liked | What to be aware of | |
|---|---|---|
| HEY | The Screener, tracking pixel warnings, HEY Calendar and the extras included, forwarding for life, no AI in the inbox | No IMAP or POP, so HEY’s apps only; every new sender is a decision; your own domain is a separate, dearer plan; US only |
| Fastmail | Speed and search, any mail app, your own domain included, Masked Email, quick and friendly support, no AI in the inbox | Nothing quite like the Screener; plainer design; less storage on personal plans; not end to end encrypted; Australian company |
For me, it’s Fastmail. HEY asked some really good questions about what email should be, and some of its answers, like the Screener and forwarding for life, are brilliant. But I need email to fit around my work, not the other way round, and Fastmail does that, costs less and never locks you in.
Try Fastmail and save 10% on your first year
You can try Fastmail free for 30 days. If you decide to stay, signing up through my referral link gives you 10% off your first year.
Start your free Fastmail trial
Referral link: I may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Frequently asked questions
Is HEY cheaper than Fastmail?
No. HEY for You is $99 a year, while Fastmail Individual is $60 a year billed yearly. With your own domain the gap is bigger: HEY for Domains starts at $10 a month, and Fastmail Individual includes a domain.
Can I use HEY with Apple Mail or Outlook?
No. HEY doesn’t support IMAP or POP, so you use HEY’s own web, desktop and phone apps. Fastmail works with any normal mail app.
Can I use my own domain with HEY?
Yes, but only on HEY for Domains, which is a separate plan at $12 per person a month ($10 for the first person). HEY for You uses an @hey.com address.
Does either service put AI in your inbox?
No. Neither has built in AI writing or sorting. Both let you connect an assistant you choose, HEY through its command line tool and Fastmail through its MCP server.
Can I try both before paying?
Yes. Fastmail has a 30 day free trial and HEY has a free trial too, so you can try either alongside your current email first.
Disclosure: I’m a member of Fastmail’s partner programme, so some Fastmail links on this site may earn me a commission at no extra cost to you. HEY doesn’t pay me anything. Neither company has seen or approved this article, and the partnership hasn’t changed my verdict.
Sources
- Hey (email service), Wikipedia
- Features, HEY
- Pricing, Fastmail
- Fastmail, Wikipedia
- Pricing, HEY
- FAQs, HEY
- Send from an external address, HEY
- Using AI agents with HEY, HEY Help
- An MCP server for Fastmail, Fastmail, Apr 2026
- The Screener, HEY
- Masked Email, Fastmail
- Masked Email in Fastmail, 1Password Support
- Using Bitwarden with Fastmail, Fastmail Help
- Multi-window support, Fastmail, Mar 2026
- EU data region, Fastmail, Aug 2026
- How HEY works, HEY
Note: checked and updated 17 October 2026. Sources: Fastmail pricing, Fastmail 2024 pricing and plan updates, Fastmail referrals, HEY pricing, HEY for Families.
Paul O'Brien
I've spent over 25 years working hands-on with email, DNS and cloud infrastructure. I test email providers and privacy tools for real, then tell you what they're good at and where they fall short.
More about meEverything I've written about Fastmail
The Microsoft Outage: Why Relying on Big Tech Has Consequences5 min read
Proton Mail vs Fastmail 2026: Privacy or Productivity?13 min read
Why Masked Email Beats Disposable Email for Most People11 min read
Microsoft Outlook and Exchange Review: Strengths, Limits5 min read
Fastmail Security and Privacy in 2026: Where Your Data Lives14 min read
Proton Mail to Fastmail: Why I Switched and How to Move7 min read
Fastmail Review 2026: Pricing, Privacy and Features Rated9 min read More like this
You're subscribed. New articles come by email, as I publish or every Thursday. Change how often


Comments