Paul O'Brien everything email Subscribe

This post contains referral links. They're marked, and they never change the verdict. How I cover site costs

Paul O'Brien
Paul O'Brien
· 8 min read

I Moved My Email From Google Workspace to Fastmail in 26 Minutes

On 17 November I moved my own email from Google Workspace to Fastmail. From the welcome screen to 2,581 emails, 78 contacts and 668 calendar events sitting in Fastmail took 26 minutes, and that includes cleaning up years of DNS clutter and fixing the mistakes I made along the way. Here's exactly what I did, with real screenshots.

Jump to section
  1. My move at a glance
  2. Signing up
  3. Adding my domain
  4. The DNS records
  5. The mistakes I made
  6. Importing from Google
  7. My addresses
  8. What I'm keeping Google for
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. The bottom line
My move to Fastmail, with the Google and Fastmail logos

I’ve written plenty about Fastmail, and I’ve moaned about being locked in to Google Workspace for 12 months. On Tuesday 17 November I stopped writing about it and moved my own email. I took screenshots as I went, so this is exactly what happened, mistakes and all.

If you want the full how to, my step by step guide to moving from Google Workspace to Fastmail and my Fastmail custom domain setup guide cover every option. This post is just my move, on one Tuesday morning, from a Google Workspace account to Fastmail with my own domain, paulobrien.com.

Short answer: it took me 26 minutes from Fastmail’s welcome screen at 11:15 to having all my mail, contacts and calendars in Fastmail at 11:41. Adding the domain and getting every DNS check green took 21 minutes, and most of that was me tidying up old records and fixing my own mistakes. The import from Google itself took about two minutes and brought across 2,581 emails, 78 contacts and 668 calendar events without missing one.

Reader offer: 10% off Fastmail. Try Fastmail free for up to 30 days, then get 10% off your first year on any plan through my referral link.

Claim 10% off Fastmail

Referral link: I may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

My move at a glance

Here’s the whole morning, from the times on my screenshots and in Fastmail’s own emails.

TimeStepWhat happened
11:15Signed upWelcome screen with a 30 day free trial
11:20Paid for the yearIndividual plan, £54 a year including VAT
11:21Added my domainTold Fastmail my domain is registered with Cloudflare
11:28DNS recordsFastmail gave me Cloudflare specific steps with copy buttons
11:28 to 11:36Tidy up and fixesCleared out old records and fixed three mistakes
11:36All greenMX, DKIM and SPF all correctly set up
11:39Import startedMail, contacts and calendars from Google Workspace
11:41Import finished2,581 emails, 78 contacts, 668 calendar events

Signing up

The first thing I noticed was the onboarding. It’s very nice. You land on a clean welcome screen that tells you how long your trial has left and gives you four things to do next: download the app, import your data, secure your account and view the plans. No upsell pop ups, no tour you can’t skip.

Fastmail's welcome screen saying Welcome to Fastmail, your free trial ends in 30 days, with a card listing Download the app, Import your data, Secure your account and View our plans, and a Welcome to Fastmail email in the inbox at 11:15 AM.
Welcome screen: a 30 day trial and four clear next steps.

I didn’t bother waiting out the trial. I’ve used Fastmail enough to know I’m staying, so I paid for the Individual plan for a year straight away: £4.50 a month, £54 a year including VAT.

Fastmail Billing and Plan page showing the Individual plan at 4.50 pounds a month for Paul O'Brien, with a next bill line saying Individual, paying yearly, next renews Wed, Nov 17, 2027 for 54 pounds including VAT.
My plan: Individual, paid yearly, £54 including VAT.

Adding my domain

Under Settings, Domains, Fastmail asks whether you want to use a domain you already own or buy a new one. Buying a domain through Fastmail only unlocks once your paid account is seven days old, which I hadn’t known. I already own paulobrien.com, so that didn’t matter to me.

Fastmail Add domain page with two choices: Use a domain you already own, where Fastmail can host the email and optionally DNS and websites, and Buy a new domain, greyed out with a note saying Available for paid accounts more than 7 days old.
Add domain: buying a new domain needs a paid account at least seven days old.

Then it’s a short set of questions. What’s the domain? Do you own it? Where is it registered? That last one is optional, but it’s worth answering, because Fastmail then gives you instructions for your own provider. Mine is Cloudflare.

Fastmail Add domain form with paulobrien.com typed into the Your domain box and the message Looks good! underneath, with Continue and Cancel buttons.
Your domain: type it in and Fastmail checks it as you go.

Next it asks for your main address and what should happen to mail sent to any other address at the domain. I put in me@paulobrien.com. The choice for everything else is rejected, which is the default, or sent to you. Rejected keeps spam down, and sent to you means nothing bounces if people use an old address.

Fastmail Email addresses at paulobrien.com page with My email is me @paulobrien.com and the note Great choice, then Mail sent to any other address at paulobrien.com will be rejected or sent to me, a switch to allow non-admins to make aliases, and a link to set up email addresses individually.
Your addresses: pick your main address and decide what happens to everything else.

The DNS records

This is the part people worry about, and Fastmail makes it as painless as it can be. Because I’d said Cloudflare, I got step by step instructions for Cloudflare, with a copy button next to every value. Fastmail is upfront that your email won’t work until you’ve made the changes, and that it can’t make them for you.

Fastmail Get instructions page for Cloudflare. Steps: log in to Cloudflare, click DNS for paulobrien.com, add two MX records for eu1-smtp.messagingengine.com priority 10 and eu2-smtp.messagingengine.com priority 20, DKIM records already ticked green, and an SPF TXT record v=spf1 include:spf.messagingengine.com ?all, with a red MX and SPF records needed warning and Check now and Close and check it later buttons.
Cloudflare instructions: each value has its own copy button.

Interestingly, my account was given Fastmail’s EU mail servers. These are the records I added for my domain:

TypeNameValuePriority
MX@eu1-smtp.messagingengine.com10
MX@eu2-smtp.messagingengine.com20
CNAMEfm1._domainkeyfm1.paulobrien.com.dkim.fmhosted.com
CNAMEfm2._domainkeyfm2.paulobrien.com.dkim.fmhosted.com
CNAMEfm3._domainkeyfm3.paulobrien.com.dkim.fmhosted.com
TXT@v=spf1 include:spf.messagingengine.com ?all

Your DKIM records will have your own domain in them, and your account may be given different MX servers. Always copy them from Fastmail’s own screen.

Good to know: in Cloudflare, set the three DKIM CNAME records to DNS only (the grey cloud), not proxied.

The mistakes I made

When I opened my DNS in Cloudflare, my first reaction was that there were way too many records. Years of trying out email services had left records behind for Amazon SES, Brevo, Postmark, Resend, Mailgun and Cloudflare’s own email sending, on top of Google. I wanted only what I actually needed, and in my rush I made a few mistakes. Here they are, so you don’t make them too.

My mistakeWhat it didThe fix
Added Fastmail’s MX record but left Google’s in placeBoth at priority 10, so incoming mail went to either Google or Fastmail more or less at randomDeleted the Google MX record
Typed the server name into the Name box for the second MX recordThe record sat on a made up subdomain, so Fastmail’s backup server got nothingChanged the Name to @
Added Fastmail’s SPF record next to Google’sTwo SPF records at the root make both of them invalidDeleted Google’s, leaving only Fastmail’s
Deleted the Amazon SES records with the other old onesMy newsletter sends through SES, so it would have started failingPut the five SES records straight back

Watch out: before you delete an old DNS record, check whether anything still uses it. My website and newsletter send email from my domain through other services, and their records have nothing to do with where my inbox lives. Cloudflare also locks the records its own email sending uses, and those need to stay.

Once that was sorted, my DNS was down to a short, tidy list.

Cloudflare DNS records for paulobrien.com after the tidy up: the three Fastmail DKIM CNAME records set to DNS only, the www CNAME, three locked cf-bounce MX records for Cloudflare email sending, MX records for eu2-smtp and eu1-smtp.messagingengine.com, the DMARC and SPF TXT records, Google site verification and two Worker routes.
After the tidy up: Fastmail’s records, plus only what my site and newsletter still need.

Back in Fastmail I pressed Check now, and at 11:36 everything was green: MX, DKIM and SPF all correctly set up. That was 21 minutes after the welcome screen, and it would have been a lot quicker without my clean up and my mistakes.

Fastmail domain page for paulobrien.com saying Your domain is correctly set up to send and receive mail, your email is delivered through our EU mail servers, with green ticks for MX, DKIM and SPF, and a note that DNS is not hosted at Fastmail.
All green: paulobrien.com set up to send and receive mail through Fastmail.

Side note: Fastmail mentions setting MX records for *.paulobrien.com if you want it to handle mail for subdomains too. I left that alone, because my sending services use subdomains for their bounce handling.

Importing from Google

Importing is under Settings, Migration. Google Workspace is top of the list, and you sign in to Google and let Fastmail in. I switched my MX records first and imported straight after, so anything that arrived at Google before the switch came across too.

Fastmail Import page listing Gmail / Google Workspace, Outlook.com / Office 365, iCloud, Yahoo Mail, HEY (upload MBOX files), Other (IMAP / CardDAV / CalDAV) and Upload contacts and calendars.
Import: Google Workspace, Microsoft, iCloud, Yahoo, HEY and any IMAP account.

I started it at 11:39. Fastmail emailed me to say contacts and calendars were done at 11:40 and mail at 11:41. That’s about two minutes, with nothing missed.

Fastmail import history showing Mail completed, 2,581 of 2,581 messages imported, Contacts completed, 78 of 78 contacts imported, and Calendars completed, 668 of 668 events imported, each with a View report link.
Import complete: every message, contact and event came across.
WhatImported
Emails2,581 of 2,581
Contacts78 of 78
Calendar events668 of 668
Time takenAbout two minutes

My Gmail labels came across as Fastmail folders, sub folders included, and storage went from 0% to 1% of the 50 GB on my plan.

My addresses

As well as me@paulobrien.com, my website sends emails from hello@paulobrien.com. I added it as an alias under Settings, My email addresses, so anything that comes back to it lands in my inbox rather than bouncing. Each address has its own copy button, and you can add an action to file, label, forward or delete mail sent to a particular address.

What I’m keeping Google for

My Google Workspace contract runs until July 2027 and, as I wrote on the day, Google won’t let me downgrade or leave early. I’ve set it to cancel when the contract ends, and until then I’ll keep using it for Docs and Drive. My email is the bit that matters, and that now lives at Fastmail.

Google Workspace is still a good fit if your business lives in Docs, Sheets and Meet. If that’s you, my Google Workspace promo code takes 10% off your first year.

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to move from Google Workspace to Fastmail?

For me it was 26 minutes from signing up to having everything imported. The import itself took about two minutes for 2,581 emails. A bigger mailbox will take longer, but you can carry on with other things while it runs.

Do I need to move my DNS to Fastmail?

No. I kept my DNS at Cloudflare and let Fastmail handle only my email. Fastmail can host your DNS if you want it to, but you don’t have to.

Should I import before or after changing the MX records?

Either works. I changed my MX records first and imported straight after, so mail that reached Google before the switch was included in the import. If you import first, run another import afterwards to catch anything that arrived in between.

Can I keep using Google Docs and Drive?

Yes. Moving your email doesn’t touch Docs or Drive. I’m keeping them until my Workspace contract ends.

Can I delete all my old DNS records?

Only the ones nothing uses. Your inbox needs just Fastmail’s MX, DKIM and SPF records, but newsletters, contact forms and other services may send from your domain using their own records. Check before you delete, and keep your DMARC record.

The bottom line

Moving my email turned out to be the easy part. Fastmail’s onboarding is genuinely nice, the domain set up told me exactly what to do in Cloudflare, and the import from Google was over in two minutes. The only slow bit was my own DNS clutter and the mistakes I made clearing it. If you’re thinking about it, try Fastmail and give yourself half an hour.

Reader offer: 10% off Fastmail. Try Fastmail free for up to 30 days, then get 10% off your first year on any plan through my referral link.

Claim 10% off Fastmail

Referral link: I may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Disclosure: This article contains a Fastmail referral link. If you sign up through it, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, and you get 10% off your first year. Everything here is from my own move on 17 November 2026; menus and prices do change.

Paul O'Brien

Paul O'Brien

I've spent over 25 years working hands-on with email, DNS and cloud infrastructure. I test email providers and privacy tools for real, then tell you what they're good at and where they fall short.

More about me

You're subscribed. New articles come by email, as I publish or every Thursday. Change how often

How often?
Nothing else, and I never share your email. Already subscribed? Sign in

Comments