How to Switch Email Provider Without Losing Anything
The order to do things in, so you keep your old mail, contacts and address.
Jump to section
- How my own move went
- 1. Decide what happens to your address
- 2. Set up the new account first
- 3. Migrate your old mail
- 4. Transfer contacts and calendars
- 5. Forward new mail and notify key contacts
- 6. Cut over your custom domain (if applicable)
- 7. Monitor and eventually close the old account
- Common pitfalls to avoid
- Frequently asked questions
Switching email provider is far less daunting than it looks, and you don’t need to lose a single message. The secret is doing things in the right order, and keeping your old account ticking over in the background for a while.
Short answer: set up the new account first, copy your old mail across, move your contacts and calendars, then forward new mail and tell people. If you use your own domain, change your MX, SPF, DKIM and DMARC records last. Keep the old account open for a month or two before you close it.
Need specific instructions? Select your current and new providers, and I'll walk you through the move step by step, including direct links to each service's official documentation.
How my own move went
I’ve switched email provider more than once: from Gmail to Proton Mail, from Proton to Fastmail, and on 17 November 2026 I moved paulobrien.com from Google Workspace to Fastmail. I timed that last move as I went, so here is what it actually took.
| Step | How long it took me | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Sign up to setting up my domain | About 21 minutes | From Fastmail’s welcome screen at 11:15 to every check green at 11:36, including tidying my DNS. |
| Copying my old mail across | About 2 minutes | 2,581 emails, 78 contacts and 668 calendar events, all imported. |
| The fiddly part | A few minutes | My DNS had far too many records from services I’d tried over the years, plus the old Google ones. I deleted the lot apart from what I still needed. |
The one thing I’d warn you about is your DNS. If you’ve tried other email or sending services in the past, you’ll probably find old records lying about. Two SPF records, for example, make both invalid, so check you end up with just one. And I’m keeping my Google Workspace account until my contract ends, exactly as I suggest in step 7.
1. Decide what happens to your address
This is the most critical decision:
- Generic addresses (
@gmail.com,@outlook.com,@icloud.com): The domain belongs to the provider, meaning you cannot take the address with you. You will need to forward your incoming mail to your new address and notify your contacts. - Custom domains (
you@yourname.co.uk): You own the address. You point your domain’s DNS records to the new provider; nobody sending you mail will notice the transition. If you are changing provider anyway, now is the ideal time to register a custom domain so you never have to change your address again. (See my guide to email providers for custom domains.)
2. Set up the new account first
Create your new account before touching the old one, and immediately enable two-factor authentication (2FA).
Before committing, verify that your new plan's storage quota exceeds your current mailbox size. It is also worth checking their policies on exporting data, account cancellation and refunds. Each provider review on this site details these under "Before you sign up".
3. Migrate your old mail
Copying messages never deletes them from your source account, making the process safe to test. There are three primary routes:
- Integrated cloud importers (Easiest): Providers such as Proton Mail, Fastmail, Posteo and Zoho Mail offer built-in migration tools. Sign in with your old credentials, and they will pull in your folders and mail automatically in the background.
- File export and import: Download your archive directly from the source provider (e.g., Google Takeout) as an
.mboxor.emlfile, then upload it into your new provider's interface. - Desktop email client (Universal fallback): Connect both accounts to a desktop client like Mozilla Thunderbird via IMAP, then drag and drop folders from the old account into the new one. It takes time, but it works across almost every service.
Encrypted mail note: end-to-end encrypted services like Proton Mail and Tuta store mail in unreadable formats on their servers, meaning standard third-party cloud importers cannot crawl them. Moving mail in or out of these platforms requires their dedicated desktop export/import utilities.
4. Transfer contacts and calendars
Cloud importers often migrate mail while leaving address books behind:
- Contacts: Export as a
.vcf(vCard) file from your old webmail, then import it into the new account. - Calendars: Export as an
.ics(iCalendar) file and upload it into your new calendar settings.
5. Forward new mail and notify key contacts
To ensure seamless continuity:
- Set up automatic forwarding: Turn on server-side forwarding in your old account so newly arriving messages route straight to your new inbox.
- Broadcast the change: Email your key contacts from your new address and update your outgoing email signature.
- Update account logins: Work through your password manager's saved logins to switch your registered email for banking, utilities, government portals, social media and subscription services.
6. Cut over your custom domain (if applicable)
Once your historic mail is fully copied over, log in to your DNS registrar or DNS host:
- Update your MX records to direct incoming mail to your new host.
- Update your SPF TXT record to authorise the new server.
- Add the new provider's DKIM and DMARC records.
Tip: lower your DNS records' time to live (TTL) to 300 seconds (5 minutes) twenty-four hours before switching; this ensures DNS caches clear rapidly worldwide.
7. Monitor and eventually close the old account
Keep the old account active for at least one to two months until incoming forwarded mail drops to zero.
If it is a free account, you can keep forwarding enabled indefinitely. Just remember to log in directly via webmail occasionally:
- Google reserves the right to delete personal accounts after two years of inactivity.
- Microsoft deactivates and wipes an
Outlook.commailbox after one year without a webmail sign-in.
Before cancelling a paid account, always download one final, complete local backup of your mailbox.
Common pitfalls to avoid
- Closing the old account too early: Lingering newsletters, occasional invoices and overlooked acquaintances will attempt to email your old address for months.
- Pointing your domain before importing old mail: Switching MX records first means new messages start landing in a clean, empty inbox, making it far harder to spot discrepancies during migration.
- Running concurrent imports: Never start two automated import tools at the same time; you will almost certainly end up with duplicated folders and messages.
- Overlooking two-factor authentication recovery: Always ensure your 2FA backup codes and password reset mechanisms are updated before relinquishing access to an old email address.
Frequently asked questions
Will I lose my emails if I switch provider?
No. Copying mail to a new provider never deletes it from the old one, so you can import, check and try again as often as you need. Only close the old account once you have checked everything arrived and taken a final backup.
Can I keep my @gmail.com or @outlook.com address?
No. Those addresses belong to Google and Microsoft. You can keep the old account and forward its mail to your new address, which is free, but you can’t take the address itself with you. That is why I suggest using your own domain for the next move.
How long does it take to switch email provider?
Setting up the new account takes minutes. Copying years of mail can take a few hours to a day, running in the background. The DNS change for your own domain usually takes effect within an hour if you lower the TTL first.
Do I need to tell everyone my new address?
If you use your own domain, no: your address stays the same. If you are moving from a free address, tell your key contacts, update your logins and leave forwarding on for a few months to catch the rest.
Kept up to date alongside my email provider directory.
Paul O'Brien
I've spent over 25 years working hands-on with email, DNS and cloud infrastructure. I test email providers and privacy tools for real, then tell you what they're good at and where they fall short.
More about meMore like this
You're subscribed. New articles come by email, as I publish or every Thursday. Change how often



Comments