Paul O'Brien everything email Subscribe

How I score email providers

Clear, fair and unbiased. Every rating on this site is based purely on verified facts. Companies cannot buy a higher position, and affiliate links never alter a score.

In plain English

My overall score is calculated across three key areas:

  • 50% privacy and data security: where your emails are stored, whether the provider can read your messages and whether it's funded by advertising.
  • 25% fair pricing: how much the cheapest plan costs each month.
  • 25% practical everyday features: storage space, using your own domain name, calendar and contacts, working in the mail app you already like, and aliases.

Separately, I calculate a Trust score based on things a provider controls: whether its website stays online, how well it protects its own domain and your sign-in, how open it is about security, and whether it lets you export your mail and cancel online.

The full detail follows, point by point.

Overall

Privacy counts for half, price for a quarter and features for a quarter. Alias services, which forward mail rather than store it, are scored on privacy (65%) and price (35%). Nothing gets an overall score until I've confirmed its price. Self-hosted software isn't rated.

Privacy, out of 5

  • End-to-end encrypted storage built in: 1.5 (optional encryption: 0.75)
  • Company based in the UK, the EU, the EEA or Switzerland: 1 (Australia: 0.5)
  • Your data kept in the UK, the EU, the EEA or Switzerland: 1
  • Not funded by advertising, and no advertising parent company: 0.5
  • Open-source apps: 0.5
  • You can sign up and pay without giving your identity: 0.5

Price, out of 5

From the cheapest plan's monthly price in pounds: up to £1 scores 5, up to £2 scores 4.5, up to £3 scores 4, up to £4 scores 3.5, up to £5 scores 3, up to £6 scores 2.5, and anything more scores 2. Prices in dollars or euros are converted at a rough rate, so check the provider's own price before you buy.

Features, out of 5

  • Your own domain: 1
  • 15 GB or more storage: 1 (5 GB or more: 0.5)
  • Calendar and contacts: 1
  • Works in any mail app (IMAP and SMTP): 1 (through a bridge app: 0.5)
  • Aliases: 1

Trust score, out of 5

The stars above reward things a provider can't always change, such as where it's based or whether its business includes end-to-end encryption. The Trust score is separate. It counts only things a provider controls, so any provider can work towards a better score. It never changes the stars or the order of results.

  • Reliability, 1 point: website uptime over 30 days from my hourly checks. 99% or more scores 1, 98% scores 0.75, 97% scores 0.5 and 95% scores 0.25.
  • Abuse and reputation, 0.75: mail servers kept off the free blocklists for 30 days (0.5), and a published way to report abuse (0.25).
  • Email security on its own domain, 1: DMARC set to reject (0.4, or 0.2 for quarantine), MTA-STS (0.2), DNSSEC (0.2), and its website on HTTPS with HSTS (0.2).
  • Account security, 0.5: two-step sign-in (0.25) and passkeys (0.25).
  • Transparency, 0.75: a security contact (0.25), a transparency report or published policy on government requests (0.25), and a published security audit or bug bounty (0.25).
  • Fair dealing, 0.5: you can export all your mail (0.25) and cancel online (0.25).
  • Support, 0.5: a way to reach a person listed on its website (0.25) and a public status page (0.25).

I check its website, not its mail service, so uptime is read generously. A failed check is tried again before it counts, and if lots of providers fail in the same hour I assume the problem was mine and don't count that hour for anyone. A blocklist only counts if I see the listing on two separate days. Uptime and blocklists need a week of my checks before they count.

Anything I haven't confirmed yet scores nothing and shows as "Not checked yet", never as a fail. You can send me a link to the provider's own page to fill a gap, using Suggest an edit on any provider's page, and I check it.

How I keep it up to date

I watch each provider's pricing and plan pages and recheck their mail settings automatically. When something changes, I check it, update the page and add the change to the price history. Every page shows the date it was last checked.

Commission

Some providers pay me a commission when you buy through a link marked Offer. It never changes a star, the order of results or which providers I list, and most of them pay me nothing. More on my disclaimer.