Paul O'Brieneverything email Subscribe

Gmail vs Yahoo Mail

On privacy it's a tie. On price it's a tie. On features it's a tie. Here's everything side by side, last checked 25 October 2026.

Which should you choose?

  • Yahoo Mail is the better pick if you want more space for your mail: 20 GB and more years of history: it started in 1997.
FeatureGmailYahoo Mail
Overall2.52.5
Privacy0.00.0
Price5.05.0
Features4.04.0
Cheapest planFree (Google One 100 GB for more space)
Free; 100 GB about £1.59–£1.99 a month
Free (Mail Plus ad-free, 200 GB)
Free; Plus £4.99 a month (2020 price)
Free planYes, 15 GB shared with DriveYes, 20 GB
Storage15 GB20 GB
Your own domainNoNo
End-to-end encryptionNoNo
Company based in United States United States
Your data is kept in United States and worldwide United States and worldwide
Founded20041997
Free trialFreeFree
Funded by advertisingYes, or its parent company isYes, or its parent company is
Works in any mail app✓ IMAP and SMTP✓ IMAP and SMTP
Calendar and contacts✓ Yes✓ Yes
AliasesPlus addressing onlyYes
Open-source appsNoNo
Sign up without IDNoNo
White labelNoNo
Reader offerNoneNone
Last checked22 October 202625 October 2026

Want to add another? Open this in the compare tool.

How Gmail and Yahoo Mail differ

  • Cheapest plans: Gmail Free (Google One 100 GB for more space), Free; 100 GB about £1.59–£1.99 a month. Yahoo Mail Free (Mail Plus ad-free, 200 GB), Free; Plus £4.99 a month (2020 price).
  • For free, Gmail gives you a free plan (15 GB shared with Drive), and Yahoo Mail a free plan (20 GB).
  • Gmail comes with 15 GB of storage and Yahoo Mail with 20 GB of storage.
  • For extra addresses, Gmail has plus addressing only and Yahoo Mail has yes.

Gmail and Yahoo Mail: your questions

Which is more private, Gmail or Yahoo Mail?

They score the same for privacy: 0 out of 5 each. The differences are in the details, such as where your mail is kept (the United States and worldwide for Gmail, the United States and worldwide for Yahoo Mail).

Which is cheaper, Gmail or Yahoo Mail?

Their cheapest plans cost about the same: Gmail Free; 100 GB about £1.59–£1.99 a month, Yahoo Mail Free; Plus £4.99 a month (2020 price).

Do Gmail and Yahoo Mail work with my own domain?

No, neither lets you use your own domain, so your address stays on theirs.

Where do Gmail and Yahoo Mail keep my email?

Both keep it in the United States and worldwide.

Recent price changes

No price changes for either since 22 October 2026. I check regularly and add any change here with its date.

The latest headlines: Gmail news · Yahoo Mail news.

Not sold on either? Try these

Gmail vs mailbox.org · Yahoo Mail vs mailbox.org · Gmail vs Posteo · Yahoo Mail vs Posteo · Gmail vs Proton Mail · Yahoo Mail vs Proton Mail

Switching between them

Moving to Gmail · Moving from Gmail. Or see all my switching guides.

Get new posts and become a member

You're subscribing to Paul O'Brien - Insights, my newsletter. When I publish a new review, guide or explainer, it comes straight to your inbox. It's free, and you also become a member.

See everything members get

I'll send one email first so you can confirm it's you. Already subscribed? Sign in to manage your details