AOL Mail vs SimpleLogin
On privacy it's SimpleLogin. On price it's AOL Mail. On features it's AOL Mail. Here's everything side by side, last checked 25 October 2026.
Should you pick AOL Mail or SimpleLogin?
- Go for AOL Mail if you'd like email without paying for it; freedom to use the mail app you already like; and calendar and contacts in the same account.
- SimpleLogin suits you best if you want your email to stay in the EU; email from a company that doesn't make money from adverts; and email at your own domain name.
| Feature | AOL Mail | SimpleLogin |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | 2.0 | 3.5 |
| Privacy | 0.0 | 3.0 |
| Price | 5.0 | 4.0 |
| Features | 3.5 | Not rated |
| Cheapest plan | Free Free | Premium $36 a year (with Proton Pass) |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes, 10 aliases |
| Storage | Not confirmed | Forwards only |
| Your own domain | No | ✓ Yes |
| End-to-end encryption | No | No |
| Company based in | United States | Switzerland (Proton) |
| Your data is kept in | United States | EU |
| Founded | 1993 | 2019 |
| Free trial | Free | Free plan |
| Funded by advertising | Yes, or its parent company is | No |
| Works in any mail app | ✓ IMAP and SMTP | No, its own apps only |
| Calendar and contacts | ✓ Yes | No |
| Aliases | Yes | Unlimited aliases |
| Open-source apps | No | ✓ Yes |
| Sign up without ID | No | No |
| White label | No | No |
| Reader offer | None | None |
| Last checked | 22 October 2026 | 25 October 2026 |
Want to add another? Open this in the compare tool.
Where they differ
- AOL Mail's cheapest plan is Free (Free); SimpleLogin's is Premium ($36 a year (with Proton Pass)).
- AOL Mail has a free plan (); SimpleLogin has a free plan (10 aliases).
- Space: AOL Mail gives storage not confirmed, SimpleLogin no storage, as it forwards mail on.
- Your mail is stored in the United States with AOL Mail, and in the EU with SimpleLogin.
- The companies sit under different laws: AOL Mail in United States, SimpleLogin in Switzerland (Proton).
- You can use your own domain with SimpleLogin, but not with AOL Mail.
- Mail apps: AOL Mail works in any mail app over IMAP; SimpleLogin only works in its own apps.
- AOL Mail (or its parent company) makes money from advertising; SimpleLogin doesn't.
- Aliases: AOL Mail offers yes, SimpleLogin unlimited aliases.
Common questions
Is AOL Mail more private than SimpleLogin?
SimpleLogin scores 3 out of 5 for privacy and AOL Mail 0. SimpleLogin gives you your email to stay in the EU, email from a company that doesn't make money from adverts and open-source apps.
Is AOL Mail cheaper than SimpleLogin?
AOL Mail costs nothing to start (Free). SimpleLogin's cheapest plan, Premium, is $36 a year (with Proton Pass). SimpleLogin has a free plan too: 10 aliases.
Can I use my own domain with AOL Mail or SimpleLogin?
Only SimpleLogin does (Yes). With AOL Mail your address stays on its own domain.
Where is my email stored with AOL Mail and SimpleLogin?
AOL Mail keeps it in the United States. SimpleLogin keeps it in the EU.
Can I use AOL Mail and SimpleLogin in Apple Mail or Outlook?
AOL Mail works in any mail app over IMAP. SimpleLogin only works in its own apps.
Recent price changes
Neither price has changed since my first check on 22 October 2026.
The latest headlines: AOL Mail news · SimpleLogin news.
Also worth a look
AOL Mail vs mailbox.org · SimpleLogin vs mailbox.org · AOL Mail vs Posteo · SimpleLogin vs Posteo · AOL Mail vs Proton Mail · SimpleLogin vs Proton Mail
Moving your email
Moving between any two providers works the same way. Pick your two providers for the steps.