Paul O'Brieneverything email Subscribe

Purelymail vs 123 Reg

In short: they tie on privacy, Purelymail wins on price, and they tie on features. The full comparison is below, last checked 25 October 2026.

Which should you choose?

  • Purelymail is the better pick if you want to pay less: $10 a year, any number of users and domains.
FeaturePurelymail123 Reg
Overall2.52.0
Privacy0.50.5
Price5.03.5
Features3.53.5
Cheapest planSimple
$10 a year, any number of users and domains
10 GB mailbox
£1.99 a mailbox a month for the first year, then £47.88 a year
Free planNoNo
StorageNot confirmed10 GB
Your own domain✓ Unlimited✓ Yes
End-to-end encryptionNoNo
Company based in United States United Kingdom (GoDaddy)
Your data is kept in United StatesNot confirmed
FoundedUnknown2000
Free trialFree trial with a small amount of credit (about a month of light use)Unknown
Funded by advertisingNoNo
Works in any mail app✓ IMAP and SMTP✓ IMAP and SMTP
Calendar and contactsNoNo
AliasesYesYes
Open-source appsNoNo
Sign up without IDNoNo
White labelUnknownUnknown
Reader offerNoneNone
Last checked25 October 202625 October 2026

Want to add another? Open this in the compare tool.

The key differences

  • Purelymail's cheapest plan is Simple ($10 a year, any number of users and domains); 123 Reg's is 10 GB mailbox (£1.99 a mailbox a month for the first year, then £47.88 a year).
  • Purelymail comes with storage not confirmed and 123 Reg with 10 GB of storage.
  • Your mail is stored in the United States with Purelymail, and in Not confirmed with 123 Reg.
  • Purelymail is based in the United States and 123 Reg in the United Kingdom (GoDaddy), so different privacy laws apply.

Purelymail and 123 Reg: your questions

Which is more private, Purelymail or 123 Reg?

They score the same for privacy: 0.5 out of 5 each. The differences are in the details, such as where your mail is kept (the United States for Purelymail, Not confirmed for 123 Reg).

Which is cheaper, Purelymail or 123 Reg?

Purelymail is cheaper. Its Simple plan is $10 a year, any number of users and domains, against £1.99 a mailbox a month for the first year, then £47.88 a year for 123 Reg's 10 GB mailbox. Check the renewal price before you pay, as some first-year prices go up.

Do Purelymail and 123 Reg work with my own domain?

Yes, both do. Purelymail: Unlimited. 123 Reg: Yes.

Where do Purelymail and 123 Reg keep my email?

Purelymail keeps it in the United States. 123 Reg keeps it in Not confirmed.

Price changes and news

  • 22 October 2026 123 Reg: £1.19 a month, when I checked

The latest headlines: Purelymail news · 123 Reg news.

Alternatives to Purelymail and 123 Reg

Purelymail vs mailbox.org · 123 Reg vs mailbox.org · Purelymail vs Posteo · 123 Reg vs Posteo · Purelymail vs Proton Mail · 123 Reg vs Proton Mail

Switching between them

Whichever you choose, the move follows the same steps. Pick your two providers for the steps.

Get new posts and become a member

You're subscribing to Paul O'Brien - Insights, my newsletter. When I publish a new review, guide or explainer, it comes straight to your inbox. It's free, and you also become a member.

See everything members get

I'll send one email first so you can confirm it's you. Already subscribed? Sign in to manage your details